Evict first, pay later: The true cost of taking the law into your own hands
Evict first, pay later: The true cost of taking the law into your own hands
Beth Donaldson & Kati Savtsenko, Property Disputes
In December 2025, the High Court in WLP Trading & Marketing Ltd v Adham Albalous & Anor upheld substantial damages awards against a landlord who took the law into its own hands. The landlord sought possession of their property by serving a Section 21 notice on two of their tenants that expired at different dates at the beginning of 2022. Prior to the expiry of the notice and therefore without a possession order, the landlord began pressuring the tenants to leave. The landlord disconnected water and electricity supplies to the individual flats, stripped and emptied the flats of the tenants’ belongings and even stationed a guard dog at the property to prevent re-entry.
The County Court described the conduct as appalling and awarded each tenant more than £150,000 for unlawful eviction, trespass to their property, destruction of their personal property, harassment, aggravated damages to reflect the distress and high-handed nature of the conduct and exemplary damages to mark a deliberate decision to evict without lawful authority and repayment of deposits. The court made clear that where a landlord evicts in the expectation that redevelopment or financial gain will outweigh the consequences, substantial punitive awards may follow.
The landlord appealed, arguing that the awards were excessive. The High Court rejected those arguments, finding that the trial judge had been entitled to reach the conclusions he did given the seriousness of the conduct and its impact on the tenants. Apart from a small reduction to one item of expense, the appeal was dismissed and the six-figure awards remained in place.
This case cements the importance of following the correct procedure when it comes to eviction of tenants and indeed acts as a stark warning that bypassing the proper legal route to possession can result in damages far exceeding any short-term commercial advantage.
Ask the team
Got a question about something we have covered in this update? Get in touch, we’re happy to answer any follow-up queries on the topics included.
Expert commentary & updates
Murphy v Maguire: Section 21’s brief reprieve cut short
What did Murphy v Maguire mean for Section 21 notices? Beth Donaldson and Kati Savtsenko, from our Property Disputes Team, outline the latest property litigation update and its implications for landlords and tenants.
The small print gets bigger: New tenant information regulations
What are the new tenant information regulations for commercial property? Beth Donaldson and Kati Savtsenko. from our Property Disputes Team, outline key requirements and how they affect landlords and tenants in the UK.
Resolving real estate disputes and managing risk
Amandeep Dhillon, from our Property Disputes Team, explains how real estate disputes can be resolved and how property owners can manage legal risk with expert strategies.
Renters Rights Act 2025: What landlords and tenants need to know
Beth Donaldson, from our Property Disputes Team, explains the Renters’ Rights Act 2025, its key changes for landlords and tenants, and what you need to know ahead of implementation.
Getting to know Amandeep Dhillon
Get to know Amandeep Dhillon, from our Dispute Resolution Team, including his experience, focus areas and approach to resolving real estate disputes.
Commercial Litigation and Dispute Resolution expert joins Hay & Kilner
Hay & Kilner welcomes a commercial litigation and dispute resolution expert to its team, strengthening the firm’s capability to support complex legal disputes with specialist expertise.
Negligence verdict secured by Hay & Kilner against asset protection firm over care home fees
Hay & Kilner secures a professional negligence verdict against an asset protection firm over care home fees, showcasing expert legal support in complex negligence claims.
You may also need advice on
Dispute Resolution
With one of the largest teams in the North East and a wealth of experience across a wide range of disputes and sectors, we get involved at the onset to help resolve the matter at an early stage saving you valuable time and money, helping you mitigate risk to reputation and maintaining valuable relationships settled.
Leave us a message
Send us your query and we will be back in touch as soon as possible.
For the latest insights, updates and events join our mailing list